Crane operation is of great significance to the busy port operations. There are two common types of cranes used in ports: wheeled cranes and rail – mounted cranes. Each of these two types of cranes has its own advantages, and the best choice depends on the specific needs and characteristics of the port. Let’s take a detailed look at the characteristics of these two types of cranes to determine which one is the best option.
Mobility and Flexibility
Wheeled Cranes
Wheeled cranes are equipped with wide and sturdy tires, allowing them to move freely on various terrains in the port area. With an independent traction system similar to that of a truck, as long as the ground can bear the weight of the crane, they can run smoothly on concrete or asphalt pavements. This mobility enables them to move quickly from one work area to another, such as from the storage area to the loading and unloading area. Sometimes, they can even operate outside the port. However, on uneven or soft ground, their performance will be limited because the tires may sink in and the crane may become unstable.
Rail-Mounted Cranes
Rail – mounted cranes run on rails installed on the port ground. These rails can guide the crane to move along a set route, usually covering key areas such as container yards or along the wharf. Although this rail system ensures precise positioning of the crane’s working area, it also severely restricts mobility. Rail – mounted cranes are confined within the rails and cannot operate in areas without pre – installed rails.
Stability and Precision
Wheeled Cranes
Rail – mounted cranes, running on fixed rails, have good stability. The rails provide a solid foundation, minimizing vibrations or swings during traveling or lifting. This stability is crucial when handling heavy containers or bulk cargo. Rail – mounted cranes are also excellent in terms of precision, as the rails can guide the crane to an exact position. For example, they can accurately place containers in the designated area, thus improving the degree of automation and operating efficiency.
Rail-Mounted Cranes
Operating on fixed rails, rail-mounted cranes offer excellent stability. The rails provide a firm foundation, minimizing vibrations or swaying during movement or lifting. This stability is especially important when handling heavy containers or bulk cargo. Rail-mounted cranes also excel in precision, as the rails guide the crane to exact locations. For example, they can place containers accurately in designated spots, enhancing automation and operational efficiency.
Complexity and Lifting Capacity
Wheeled Cranes
Wheeled cranes have a relatively simple design, consisting of a wheeled chassis and an upper structure, which includes components such as the boom, hoisting mechanism, and slewing system. They are compactly designed and do not need to be integrated into a railway system, making them easy to install and maintain. However, this simplicity limits their lifting capacity, generally only up to several dozen tons. The weight that the tires and chassis can bear determines the lifting limit.
Rail-Mounted Cranes
Rail – mounted cranes have a more complex structure. In addition to the common hoisting, slewing, and boom – arm mechanisms, they also include components such as running wheels, drive motors, gearboxes, and rail cleaning devices to ensure smooth operation along the rails. This design is conducive to increasing the lifting capacity, enabling them to easily handle heavy loads of hundreds of tons. They are the ideal choice for loading and unloading heavy goods from large container ships or bulk carriers.
Applications and Cost-Effectiveness
Wheeled Cranes
Wheeled cranes are versatile and can be used in a variety of situations. They are suitable for handling small and medium – sized goods, short – distance transportation in the port, warehouse stacking, or temporary lifting tasks. For example, they are often used to move small equipment in port warehouses. Due to their simple structure and no need for rail installation, the initial investment is relatively low. However, due to tire wear and chassis maintenance, the maintenance cost may be high. Fuel consumption is another cost factor to consider.
Rail-Mounted Cranes
Rail – mounted cranes are mainly used in large container terminals or bulk cargo terminals. In container terminals, they efficiently move containers between ships and storage areas, while in bulk cargo terminals, they handle heavy materials such as coal and ore. Their initial investment is high because it includes the crane and a large amount of rail infrastructure. However, they have a long service life and the operating costs remain stable in the long term.
Conclusion
The choice between a wheeled crane and a rail – mounted crane depends on the specific needs of the port. If the port handles a large amount of heavy goods and requires high – precision operations, a rail – mounted crane may be the best choice. However, for ports that need greater flexibility and handle various small and medium – sized goods, wheeled cranes can provide more convenience and a higher cost – performance ratio.
At GloryTrack, we not only provide crane rails but also crane accessories. If you are interested in these accessories, please feel free to contact us!